WHY PALESTINIANS WILL HAVE NO STATE
Palestinian Moslems are killing fellow Palestinian Moslems in
violent clashes in the Gaza Strip. The trigger for this recent violence
between warring factions of Hamas and Fatah was the call for early
elections by former Palestinian Prime Minister Mahmoud Abbasf
Middle
East expert Avi Lipkin in conducting interviews on the topic of
why, in his opinion, the Palestinians will not have their own
independent State. The following is an article by Avi on this subject.
PALESTINIAN MOSLEMS ARE THEIR OWN WORST ENEMY
They Will Not Have Their Own State Because They Keep Fighting Each Other
By Avi Lipkin (249 words)
There are two primary guidelines as to how things will develop in Gaza
and the West Bank.
Firstly, the only country in the world where Moslems/Arabs/Palestinians
are able to vote freely and enjoy the democratic process is the Jewish
State of Israel, where Israeli Arabs can participate in virtually all
aspects of Israeli life. The brothers of the Israeli Arabs, the
Palestinians, are ruled by guns. Whoever has the most guns wins. This
is why Fatah will militarily overthrow the Hamas in conjunction with
the upcoming elections declared by former Palestinian Prime MinisterAbu
Mazen.
Secondly, neither the Hamas nor the PLO backed Abu Mazen can really do
anything for their people, because they are both dedicated to the
destruction of Israel, the Hamas calling on Israel's destruction today,
and the PLO calling on Israel's destruction some time in the future.
The reason there will never be a Palestinian State is because in order
to have a state, you must have a viable economy. In order for the
Palestinians to have a viable economy, they must make peace with
Israel-- real peace. Since this is unthinkable to most true believing
Middle East Moslems, there will never be peace; therefore there will
never be a viable economy, therefore, there will never be a Palestinian
state. Therefore civil war will continue between Hamas and PLO and much
innocent blood will be shed.
Until the Palestinian Moslems learn to put bread and butter before guns
and bullets, there will be no Palestinian State.
THE FOLLOWING NEWS STORY MAY BE HELPFUL FOR SHOW PREP:
December 18, 2006
After Deadly Gaza Clashes,
Leaders Appeal for Calm
By STEVEN ERLANGER
JERUSALEM, Dec. 17 — The Palestinian Authority president, Mahmoud
Abbas, and the acting speaker of the Palestinian parliament, Ahmed
Baher of Hamas, appealed separately to militants of all stripes to lay
down their arms on Sunday after a day of rallies and violent clashes in
the Gaza Strip.
The violence, which both Hamas and Fatah used to send messages of
strength after Mr. Abbas ordered early elections, included mortar fire
and gun battles around the presidential compound that killed two
security officers and a 19-year-old passer-by and wounded 15 other
people.
As gunmen attacked forces loyal to Mr. Abbas, Fatah forces took over
two ministries, using their roofs as firing platforms as they tried to
secure a wider area around the presidential compound.
After nightfall, the armed groups agreed on a cease-fire and the
removal of armed men from the streets, said Hamas and Fatah spokesmen.
But the cease-fire may prove shaky as others have before it.
Earlier, Mr. Abbas, who was not in Gaza, issued a statement calling for
restraint, saying, “I ask the people to show steadfastness and national
spirit and avoid provocations intended to destroy the democracy and
blow up the situation.”
Mr. Baher, speaking for Hamas, said: “We ask all armed people to leave
the streets and stop fighting. We ask people not to use weapons to
solve political issues and not to take political issues to the street.”
On Saturday, Mr. Abbas, who leads Fatah, said he was fed up with the
failure of Hamas to negotiate seriously on a new unity government and
he ordered early presidential and parliamentary elections. Hamas
rejected early parliamentary elections as illegal, saying that it was a
blatant effort to overturn their majority, won in free elections 11
months ago. They accused Mr. Abbas of following an American and Israeli
agenda.
But any election, if it happens, would be at least four to six months
away, election officials said on Sunday. Many Palestinians are hoping
that Hamas and Fatah will resume negotiations on a unity government to
short-circuit this building crisis.
The Hamas interior minister, Siad Siam, said that “the security
situation is very tense due to the political conflict and to the
incitement campaign and accusations.” He called on all factions for “a
political decision to stop this deterioration,” adding, “We’re seeking
to put an end to what is happening but it’s not as easy as some think.”
Among those wounded on Sunday was a girl, 10, and a correspondent for
the French newspaper Libération, Didier François, 46, who
was hit by a bullet in the leg and was taken to Al Shifa hospital in
Gaza, where he was said to be in satisfactory condition. Fatah held a
huge rally in the Jabaliya refugee camp, but a colonel in the security
service, a 40-year-old member of Fatah, was abducted and killed by
masked men.
The prime minister, Ismail Haniya of Hamas, said at a cabinet meeting
on Sunday that Hamas would not participate in legislative elections.
“The government rejects the call for early legislative elections
because it’s unconstitutional and would cause wide tension among
Palestinians,” he said. He called Mr. Abbas’s speech, which harshly
criticized Hamas for bad faith and for inserting religion into
politics, “insulting to the sacrifices and the pain of Palestinians
everywhere.”
Hamas, which has regularly called for a national-unity government on
terms that do not please Fatah or the Bush administration, is
nonetheless expected to continue talking with Mr. Abbas. Although he
met with the Central Election Commission in Ramallah on Sunday, the
chairman of the commission, without commenting on the legality of the
election call, said he needed at least four months just to prepare the
voting register.
Ismail Radwan, a Hamas spokesman in Gaza, said at a rally that Hamas
“will not be driven into a civil war” by Fatah or the United States.
“The only way out is returning to the dialogue table, but in order to
respect Palestinian legitimacy, to respect people’s will,” he said.
Mr. Abbas, who was elected in January 2005, could resign to cause a new
presidential election. But many doubt that he has the legal right to
dissolve the parliament.
Mouin Rabbani, a senior analyst with the International Crisis Group, a
nonprofit organization that works to resolve conflicts, said he
believed that Hamas officials were sincere when they said they desired
a unity government based on a political document negotiated with Mr.
Abbas but opposed by Washington. He said he expected Hamas to negotiate
further with Mr. Abbas, but from a position of strength. “If Abbas and
Fatah make a serious effort to engage in new talks it will be hard for
Hamas to refuse, and hard for them to refuse further compromise,“ Mr.
Rabbani said.
Public American and British support for early elections only helps
Hamas, he said.
Polls show that support for Hamas has been slipping because of the
economic crisis facing the Palestinians, worsened by the cutoff of
Western direct aid to the Hamas-run Palestinian Authority, and the
security chaos in Gaza and large parts of the West Bank.
But Hamas could win new elections and also defeat Mr. Abbas for the
presidency, which could put an end for some time to the idea of a
two-state solution, with an independent Palestine next to Israel. Hamas
recognizes Israel as a fact, but does not accept its right to exist
permanently on what it considers Islamic land.
A poll released Sunday placed Mr. Haniya and Mr. Abbas in a dead heat
in a presidential race and suggested that Fatah is six percentage
points ahead of Hamas, 42 to 36, in a parliamentary election. But the
poll, conducted by the independent Palestinian Center for Policy and
Survey Research, has a margin of sampling error of plus or minus three
percentage points, meaning that the two factions could be tied. Mr.
Abbas also faces problems because he has done little to reform Fatah or
to fire old cronies, who are popularly considered corrupt and out of
touch with the lives of ordinary Palestinians.
Taghreed El-Khodary contributed reporting from Gaza.
Copyright 2006 The New York Times Company
ABOUT AVI…
AVI LIPKIN is cofounder of Israel Today Magazine and has served as an
Israeli Army reserves spokesman 14 years. Avi has been a guest on Sean
Hannity, Fox and Friends, Dayside with Linda Vester and other popular
radio and television programs, as well as in person in hundreds of
churches and synagogues across the U.S., Canada, Mexico, Switzerland,
France, Greece, Norway, Finland, Russia, Germany and Israel. Mordecai
speaks six languages and has received his B. A. from Hebrew University,
1973, majoring in Sovietology/Russian Studies and East European
Studies. He is well versed in the centuries of Islamic wars. He was
born in the U.S. but immigrated (made Aliyah) to Israel in 1968.
|